Well, I admit it - I clicked on this Buzzfeed link someone posted on Facebook - 77 Facts That Sound Like Huge Lies But Are Actually Completely True. There are some pretty funny and interesting things on the list. However, I note - I did not click on the link per se for entertainment. I clicked on it to see if there was anything about microbes on the list. And happily, there was. Alas, what there was, was, well, a bit wrong:
Let's start with #67. "There is 10 times more bacteria in your body than actual body cells". Well, alas, this is a nice bit of information. But it is not based on facts. See Peter Andrey Smiths wonderful article in the Boston Globe about this issue. The Buzzfeed article links to a 2010 Discover Magazine bit about this topic. So they were trying to use facts. But alas, that was not based on facts itself.
Then, let's go to #68. "And 90% of the cells that make us up of aren’t human but mostly fungi and bacteria.". So - I am at a bit of a loss on this. First, isn't this really just rehashing #67 with the addition of fungi to the story? Also - I note the math here is weird. #67 would lead one to conclude that 90.9% of the cells in your body are bacterial (10:1 = 10/11 = 90.9%). So then if one adds fungi to the picture the percent of cells in our bodies that are not human goes DOWN to 90%. How does that work exactly?
So not only do they get the 10x as many cells fact wrong, they do something really weird by basically repeating #67 and then doing some weird math.
Oh well, glad they have something on microbiomes. Too bad it came out a bit wrong.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most recent post
My Ode to Yolo Bypass
Gave my 1st ever talk about Yolo Bypass and my 1st ever talk about Nature Photography. Here it is ...
-
Just got this press release by email. I am sick of receiving dozens of unsolicited press releases, especially those in topics not related ...
-
See Isolation and sequence-based characterization of a koala symbiont: Lonepinella koalarum Paper based on PhD thesis work of Katie Dahlha...
-
I have a new friend in Google Scholar Updates I have written about the Updates system before and if you want more information please see...
No comments:
Post a Comment